We may go on endlessly debating if India needs or doesn't need a 'Bullet Train' - but when we see such developments that need huge investment (here it is INR 98000 crore, at this concept stage, and may well end up with higher figures when it is finally done) in the context of the fact that India is still home to countless slum habitations throughout its length and breadth, including its national capital Delhi, we are forced to question the relevance of such massive projects when resources should ideally be invested first in uplifting poor people.
But like it happens, everyone in the policymaking class is busy extracting mileage here with the Shakurbasti demolition incident (with visibly poor or non-existent relief measures for those displaced) - Aam Aadmi Party, BJP, Congress and everyone else, including Indian Railways, the massive Indian government outfit that reeks of corruption and inefficiency in its operations and is headed by a Rail Minister who selects only positive tweets to retweet, sifting away all those negativities. But can he?
As per Census 2011 figures, the slum population in India has gone up to 65 million from 52 million in 2001.
And the primary responsibility of any government in India should be bringing this figure down first. Bullet Trains, that anyway are nowhere near to the primary needs of rail infrastructure in India, may come later.
Because these 65 million are the just the ones who bothered to get counted. There would be, and there are many more than this figure and that should always serve as reminder for the mammoth task that lies before us - to uplift millions from poverty, to mainstream them into society - as society in a democratic country like India - the way it has been enshrined in our Constitution.
We are committing criminal offence by leaving many of our sisters and brothers out in the open, to face difficult and life threatening circumstances - like we did so in the Shakurbasti demolition case. We forced thousands out of their homes without thinking of the cold, inclement weather, without thinking how they would battle it out without roofs over their heads.
Yes, there are many parameters and their indicators that rightly vouch for India's rising global prominence - the world's youngest nation, a nation with large middle class that is slated to become the largest, among the world's largest economies, the world's fastest growing economy, the favourite marketplace of the world's companies after China, the example of successful democratic transition from a colonial past, and so on.
But unless and until we don't work on to bring uniformity in lives of ordinary Indians, we will consistently face such dilemmatic propositions on development - the paradoxes that force us to think what we need first - that how should we prioritize elements of governance in a fast moving economy that still has the maximum headcount of the world's poor.